Four problems account for the lion’s share of serious teaching problems:
- Misalignment
- Expert blind spot
- Content overload
- Over-identification
An overstatement? Perhaps, but over the many years we’ve worked with faculty in a wide range of disciplines, we’ve seen these issues undermine students’ learning, motivation, and morale in insidious ways. Easy to fall prey to, they compromise the effectiveness of even seasoned teachers. Here’s some advice on recognizing the problems, avoiding them, and preventing the host of headaches they can cause.
Misalignment
Three important elements characterize any well-designed course:
objectives (what students should know or be able to do by the end of the course),
assessments (the means used to gauge students’ progress toward those objectives), and
instruction (the methods and materials employed to help students acquire the knowledge and skills articulated in the objectives). A solid course design requires that these elements be aligned, each dovetailing with and supporting the others.
Misalignment occurs when these three elements are not in sync, in particular when the knowledge and skills being taught are not the same as those being assessed.
“I’d never do that!” you might be thinking. And of course, no one ever
means to. But it can happen more easily than most of us realize. All too often, we
teach the whats (terms, definitions, formulae) and the whys (concepts, principles) of a subject but
assess the hows (procedures, methods) and the whens (conditions of application).
Think of how we learn to drive. We study the whats and whys of the rules of the road in order to pass a written test. Then we have to pass a test of actual driving. Would studying for the written test prepare us adequately for the driving test? Of course not. Actual driving requires other knowledge, skills, and practice, for which road rules are necessary but not sufficient. If we prepared for the driving test solely by learning road rules, it would constitute misalignment: the instruction and assessment don’t line up.
To continue reading, you must be a Teaching Professor Subscriber.
Please log in or sign up for full access.
