We’re having the wrong debate about teaching methods, and this happens over and over again. Let me explain. For a long time now, the dominant approach to evaluating teaching methods has been what I’ve called the “best-practice approach,” which assumes that there exists a single best teaching method for all subjects, all teachers, and all students. If teachers follow this best practice, the logic goes, students will always and automatically learn. I’ve pointed out the flaws in this approach before, specifically that all learning is contextual. Learning emerges, if it occurs at all, from a complex interaction of multiple factors, such as the skill and knowledge of the teacher, the subject matter, and the characteristics of the students. Because learning depends on the alignment of multiple factors, there is no single best teaching method for all teachers, subjects, and students. There are no magic bullets in teaching; context makes all the difference. The effectiveness of any teaching method depends on how well teachers implement it. Any teaching method will fail when implemented inappropriately or in the wrong context. Teaching requires constant adaptation to what is happening in the class.