We’re Having the Wrong Debate About Teaching Methods . . . Again

Credit: iStock/Credit: skynesher
Credit: iStock/Credit: skynesher
We’re having the wrong debate about teaching methods, and this happens over and over again. Let me explain. For a long time now, the dominant approach to evaluating teaching methods has been what I’ve called the “best-practice approach,” which assumes that there exists a single best teaching method for all subjects, all teachers, and all students. If teachers follow this best practice, the logic goes, students will always and automatically learn. I’ve pointed out the flaws in this approach before, specifically that all learning is contextual. Learning emerges, if it occurs at all, from a complex interaction of multiple factors, such as the skill and knowledge of the teacher, the subject matter, and the characteristics of the students. Because learning depends on the alignment of multiple factors, there is no single best teaching method for all teachers, subjects, and students. There are no magic bullets in teaching; context makes all the difference. The effectiveness of any teaching method depends on how well teachers implement it. Any teaching method will fail when implemented inappropriately or in the wrong context. Teaching requires constant adaptation to what is happening in the class.

To continue reading, you must be a Teaching Professor Subscriber. Please log in or sign up for full access.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

I have two loves: teaching and learning. Although I love them for different reasons, I’ve been passionate about...
Active learning has a long history in higher education, with Bonwell and Eison’s (1991) influential report helping its...
When generative AI tools first became widely available, conversations in higher education centered on whether students should be...
On my way to teach, I sometimes pass the football team gathered in a darkened classroom, their faces...
A few years ago, I had a student (let’s call him George) whom I suspected was neurodivergent. He...
Maybe it’s just me, but my students seem to be reading less for their classes than they were...
You’ve just finished a full morning of grocery shopping in a busy supermarket. After navigating packed store aisles...

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to limited free articles, news alerts, and select newsletters

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Login here

Get unlimited access to The Teaching Professor

Stay informed. Subscribe Now.

WELCOME OFFER

$19.00 $14.00/month

for your first 6 months. Use coupon code TP6MO.

$19.00 thereafter. Cancel anytime.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of The Teaching Professor

You only have  free article views remaining.

WELCOME OFFER

$19.00 $14.00/month

for your first 6 months. Use coupon code TP6MO.

$19.00 a month thereafter. Cancel anytime.